Pavan, Week #1 - Who is Yamato?

 Let’s talk about Yamato from One Piece! Yamato has been a pretty controversial character for a couple years now and it all has to do with how they portray themself through their language and identity. Ever since they were a kid, Yamato has idolized Oden, a man who fought heroically and died trying to protect the country they grew up in, the land of Wano. The person who killed Oden was Kaido, Yamato’s father. This leads to a very strained relationship between the two, and ultimately, Yamato rebels against Kaido and aids in defeating him. 


Now, why is this character even up for debate? The backstory seems normal enough for an anime. It all comes down to what they call themself, which happens to be Oden, the name of their dead hero. Naming yourself after your hero shouldn’t be a crazy concept, but since Yamato is a biological female and Oden is male, the fandom and even outsiders exploded into argument. Some argue that because the English translation of the anime/manga sometimes uses male pronouns (VIZ media is very inconsistent and also uses female pronouns depending on the chapter), Yamato is transgender. Others believe that since the Japanese version uses semi-masculine pronouns that are consistently used by female-identifying characters, Yamato is a woman. 


What do I think? I think that whether or not Yamato is transgender is something that can only truly be revealed by the author, Eiichiro Oda, if he chooses to. Debate is fine, and you’re welcome to share your thoughts, theories, and analyses, but in my opinion, everyone is kind of missing the point. People are trying to quantify how much they use a certain pronoun or how many times they have called themself a man, but many have forgotten to consider why. Yamato calls themself a man because Oden was a man. Yamato uses masculine pronouns because Oden used them. Yamato wants to be referred to as a man purely because Oden was a man. If Oden happened to be a woman, I’m confident that Yamato would identify as a woman too and use feminine pronouns. 


Oden was a courageous man, who loved to go on adventures and fought for the people close to him and even citizens who mocked him. To follow in his footsteps is Yamato’s dream, and so they changed their pronouns and even asked to be called Oden, reflecting their wish to “become” Oden. To be Oden is what Yamato wants most in life, and so their pronouns are less about being male or female, but more about being the Yamato they once were and the Oden they hope to be. Some try to argue that it ruins the character by not giving them an identity of their own, but I disagree. Yamato and Oden share so many ideals that their identities overlap, and it only makes sense that they want to embody their hero so much. To be Oden is Yamato’s identity. 

Comments

  1. Kan XuSeptember 2, 2026 at 9:51 PM

    This was an interesting blog post to read, Pavan. I, admittedly, am not caught up with One Piece, so I do not necessarily have the full context for this blog, but I like how you talked about how gender identity plays into a character’s overall identity as a person. This discourse around gender reminds me of the game Project Sekai, where fans would debate for years and months over the gender identity of a character called Mizuki Akiyama. But, just as you point out, there are different nuances to gender. For Yamato, it is a matter of following their idol; for others, it is about what they truly feel about themselves. It opens the gate for a wider discussion revolving how gender is treated for fictional characters and in real life.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Anirudh Week 1: An Analysis of the Modern Extension of Colonial Speech

Image
Image credit:  The Penn Review In his 1986 collection of essays Decolonising The Mind , Ngũgĩ wa Thiong'o posits that the greatest weapon of colonialism wasn’t the rifle. It wasn’t the cannon nor the gunboat. It was the weaponization of language. He vividly describes the systemic tactics colonial powers used to strip down the native tongues of colonized children in favor of English, severing the children’s connections to their cultures, identities, and even self-worth. And even though these colonial empires have collapsed, the inherent framework of identity erasure has been fundamentally upgraded. Today, the maxim of colonial erasure has been repackaged by the algorithms of Artificial Intelligence. Throughout the history of AI—whether we see it as a tool of objectivity or question it with suspicion—we cannot ignore that these systems are at their core built on data. Specifically however, they are built with massive datasets scraped from the Western, English-speaking internet. It is...
Read more

Sophie, Week #1 - Why Leitmotifs are Super Cool: Building Identity Through the Language of Music

Image
When I first saw the theme for this quarter’s blog submissions, I was actually super happy! You may be thinking that I’m nuts for being excited about an assignment, but I was. I knew that I would have the chance to talk about one of my favorite things in the whole world—leitmotifs! You’ve heard the word “motif” before, a repeated idea or symbol throughout a work of literature that helps to develop a broader theme. Leitmotifs are sort of like that, but instead of a repeated written idea, they’re repeated musical phrases used to represent different things. Here, I'll discuss how they can be an invaluable technique for developing a character’s identity within a musical. I’ll give some examples from one of my favorite musicals, Sondheim’s Into the Woods. In my opinion, the easiest leitmotif to grasp is something I think of as “The Royal Fanfare.” Basically, every time the princes come on stage, you hear a trumpet fanfare. S ounds pretty simple right? The princes enter; the fanfare pla...
Read more

Arya, Week #2 - Misogyny Will Never Die: How Language Subtly Perceives Women as Less

Image
Image credit: Rusi , “ Misogyny .” I have strong opinions on my femininity. Sure, I dress as a boy sometimes, but I still have a firm identity and sense of pride around being a woman. But society does not. At practically every corner and every step, there is something inherently more difficult about being a woman. Basically, every modern society has some sort of underlying sexism. Some of it is pretty obvious like women not being able to have credit cards (essentially financial freedom) until 1974 with the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, but other times it’s not.  There are small things like how the law of Coverture made women have no legal identity at all, even being called “legally dead”. The tradition of marriage creating one simply meant that the husband was the “one”, which isn’t nearly as romantic sounding as it is today. BBC adds that the male being the default gender–called generic masculine–creates a bias, which embeds itself into our psyche so much so that a gender neu...
Read more